judge_probes.yaml

# labeled_date: when these human labels were last authored/reviewed. `sprout calibrate`
# warns (does not yet fail — see P0-4/AIEV-20) when this is more than 30 days old, per the
# ROADMAP's "judge-calibration freshness" row. Update this only when the human labels
# themselves are actually re-reviewed, not on unrelated edits.
labeled_date: "2026-07-08"
probes:
- id: g1-pothos-toxic
  kind: entails
  text_a: Pothos is toxic to cats and dogs when ingested.
  sources:
  - Pothos (Epipremnum aureum) is toxic to cats and dogs; ingestion causes oral irritation
    and drooling.
  human_label: true
- id: g2-spider-nontoxic
  kind: entails
  text_a: The spider plant is non-toxic to cats and dogs.
  sources:
  - The spider plant (Chlorophytum comosum) is listed as non-toxic to cats and dogs
    in the toxic-plant database.
  human_label: true
- id: g3-snake-watering
  kind: entails
  text_a: Water a snake plant roughly every two weeks, letting the soil dry between
    waterings.
  sources:
  - Snake plant (Sansevieria) tolerates drought; water roughly every two weeks and
    let the soil dry between waterings.
  human_label: true
- id: g4-aloe-negation-contradiction
  kind: entails
  text_a: Aloe vera is not toxic to dogs.
  sources:
  - Aloe vera is toxic to dogs and cats; ingestion can cause vomiting, diarrhea, and
    lethargy.
  human_label: false
- id: g5-aloe-safe-antonym-contradiction
  kind: entails
  text_a: Aloe vera is safe for dogs to eat.
  sources:
  - Aloe vera is toxic to dogs and cats; ingestion can cause vomiting, diarrhea, and
    lethargy.
  human_label: false
- id: c1-monstera-dry-inch
  kind: contains
  text_a: Let the top inch of soil dry before watering your Monstera again. Based
    on references as of 2024-03-01.
  text_b: let the top inch of soil dry before watering
  human_label: true
- id: c2-snake-low-light
  kind: contains
  text_a: A snake plant tolerates low light but grows fastest in bright indirect light.
  text_b: snake plant tolerates low light
  human_label: true
- id: c3-repot-interval
  kind: contains
  text_a: Repot when the roots begin to circle the pot, usually every 18 to 24 months.
  text_b: repot every 18 to 24 months
  human_label: true
- id: c4-fact-absent
  kind: contains
  text_a: This answer explains watering frequency and the plant light requirements
    in detail.
  text_b: fertilize monthly during spring and summer
  human_label: false
- id: e1-es-snake-watering-paraphrase
  kind: equivalent
  text_a: Riega la planta serpiente cada dos semanas.
  text_b: Riega la planta serpiente aproximadamente cada dos semanas.
  human_label: true
- id: e2-es-yellow-leaves-synonym-paraphrase
  kind: equivalent
  text_a: El amarilleo de las hojas suele deberse a un exceso de riego.
  text_b: Las hojas amarillas normalmente indican un exceso de riego.
  human_label: true
- id: e3-es-pothos-toxic-vs-safe
  kind: equivalent
  text_a: El potos es toxico para los gatos si lo ingieren.
  text_b: El potos es seguro para los gatos si lo ingieren.
  human_label: false
- id: g6-monstera-light
  kind: entails
  text_a: The Monstera grows best in bright, indirect light for roughly 6 to 8 hours a day.
  sources:
  - The Monstera (Monstera deliciosa) grows best in bright, indirect light for roughly 6 to 8 hours
    a day.
  human_label: true
- id: g7-monstera-toxic
  kind: entails
  text_a: Monstera is toxic to cats and dogs and ingestion can cause oral irritation and drooling.
  sources:
  - The cited reference lists Monstera (Monstera deliciosa) as toxic to cats and dogs; ingestion
    can cause oral irritation, intense burning of the mouth and lips, excessive drooling, vomiting,
    and difficulty swallowing.
  human_label: true
- id: g8-peace-lily-toxic
  kind: entails
  text_a: Peace lily is toxic to cats and dogs and ingestion can cause oral irritation and drooling.
  sources:
  - The cited reference lists Peace lily (Spathiphyllum) as toxic to cats and dogs; ingestion can
    cause oral irritation, intense burning of the mouth and lips, drooling, vomiting, and difficulty
    swallowing.
  human_label: true
- id: g9-zz-plant-watering
  kind: entails
  text_a: Water the ZZ plant only when the top 2 inches of soil have dried out completely.
  sources:
  - Water the ZZ plant only when the top 2 inches of soil have dried out completely, which often
    means every two to three weeks.
  human_label: true
- id: g10-jade-light
  kind: entails
  text_a: The Jade plant does best in bright light and tolerates several hours of direct sun each
    day.
  sources:
  - The Jade plant (Crassula ovata) does best in bright light and tolerates several hours of direct
    sun each day.
  human_label: true
- id: g11-philodendron-watering
  kind: entails
  text_a: Water Philodendron when the top one to two inches of soil have dried out.
  sources:
  - Water Philodendron when the top one to two inches of soil have dried out, which is often about
    once a week in spring and summer.
  human_label: true
- id: g12-dracaena-tips
  kind: entails
  text_a: Dracaena can develop brown leaf tips when watered with fluoride- or chlorine-heavy tap
    water.
  sources:
  - Dracaena can develop brown leaf tips when watered with fluoride- or chlorine-heavy tap water,
    so use filtered or distilled water if tips brown.
  human_label: true
- id: g13-rubber-plant-light
  kind: entails
  text_a: The Rubber plant grows best in bright, indirect light near an east- or south-facing window.
  sources:
  - The Rubber plant (Ficus elastica) grows best in bright, indirect light near an east- or south-facing
    window.
  human_label: true
- id: g14-fiddle-leaf-fig-watering
  kind: entails
  text_a: Overwatering is the most common cause of trouble for the Fiddle-leaf fig and can lead to
    root rot.
  sources:
  - Overwatering is the most common cause of trouble for the Fiddle-leaf fig and can lead to root
    rot and dropped leaves.
  human_label: true
- id: g15-orchid-toxicity
  kind: entails
  text_a: The cited reference does not list Orchid as toxic to cats or dogs.
  sources:
  - The cited reference does not list Orchid (Phalaenopsis) as toxic to cats or dogs.
  human_label: true
- id: g16-calathea-watering
  kind: entails
  text_a: Calathea prefers consistently moist soil and reacts to drought by curling and crisping
    its leaf edges.
  sources:
  - Calathea prefers consistently moist soil and reacts to drought by curling and crisping its leaf
    edges.
  human_label: true
- id: g17-boston-fern-humidity
  kind: entails
  text_a: The Boston fern resents dry air, so mist its fronds or set the pot on a humidity tray.
  sources:
  - Because the Boston fern resents dry air, mist its fronds or set the pot on a humidity tray to
    keep relative humidity near 50 to 70 percent.
  human_label: true
- id: g18-english-ivy-not-toxic-negation
  kind: entails
  text_a: English ivy is not toxic to cats and dogs.
  sources:
  - The cited reference lists English ivy (Hedera helix) as toxic to cats and dogs; ingestion can
    cause vomiting, excessive drooling, abdominal pain, and diarrhea.
  human_label: false
- id: g19-boston-fern-toxic-negation
  kind: entails
  text_a: The Boston fern is toxic to cats and dogs and ingestion causes vomiting.
  sources:
  - The cited reference does not list the Boston fern (Nephrolepis exaltata) as toxic to cats or
    dogs. According to the cited reference, the Boston fern is not associated with poisoning in household
    pets that nibble its fronds.
  human_label: false
- id: g20-zz-plant-wrong-topic
  kind: entails
  text_a: The ZZ plant needs twelve to fourteen hours of daylight to rebloom every spring.
  sources:
  - The ZZ plant grows well in low to bright indirect light, which makes the ZZ plant a forgiving
    choice for dim rooms and offices.
  human_label: false
- id: g21-orchid-wrong-topic
  kind: entails
  text_a: Repot the Orchid every eighteen to twenty-four months using a loose, well-draining mix.
  sources:
  - Water the Orchid (Phalaenopsis) about once every seven to ten days, allowing the potting medium
    to dry slightly between waterings.
  human_label: false
- id: g22-jade-plant-not-toxic-negation
  kind: entails
  text_a: The Jade plant is not toxic to cats and dogs.
  sources:
  - The cited reference lists the Jade plant (Crassula ovata) as toxic to cats and dogs; ingestion
    can cause vomiting, lethargy, loss of coordination, and a slowed heart rate.
  human_label: false
- id: g23-calathea-toxic-negation
  kind: entails
  text_a: Calathea is toxic to cats and dogs.
  sources:
  - The cited reference does not list Calathea as toxic to cats or dogs.
  human_label: false
- id: g24-spider-plant-wrong-topic
  kind: entails
  text_a: Fertilize the Spider plant monthly during spring and summer with a balanced houseplant
    fertilizer.
  sources:
  - The Spider plant grows best in bright, indirect light near an east- or north-facing window.
  human_label: false
- id: g25-dracaena-wrong-topic
  kind: entails
  text_a: Dracaena flowers profusely indoors and produces fragrant white blooms twice a year.
  sources:
  - Dracaena (Dracaena) grows best in bright, indirect light but tolerates medium and lower light
    with slower growth.
  human_label: false
- id: g26-monstera-safe-antonym-contradiction
  kind: entails
  text_a: Monstera is safe for cats and dogs to chew on.
  sources:
  - The cited reference lists Monstera (Monstera deliciosa) as toxic to cats and dogs; ingestion
    can cause oral irritation, intense burning of the mouth and lips, excessive drooling, vomiting,
    and difficulty swallowing.
  human_label: false
- id: g27-english-ivy-harmless-antonym-contradiction
  kind: entails
  text_a: English ivy is harmless for dogs to chew on and causes no reaction.
  sources:
  - The cited reference lists English ivy (Hedera helix) as toxic to cats and dogs; ingestion can
    cause vomiting, excessive drooling, abdominal pain, and diarrhea.
  human_label: false
- id: c5-monstera-winter-watering
  kind: contains
  text_a: In winter, water your Monstera much less often, roughly once every 2 to 3 weeks, since
    growth slows down. Based on references as of 2026-05-01.
  text_b: in winter the monstera needs less frequent watering, often only once every 2 to 3 weeks
  human_label: true
- id: c6-peace-lily-wilting
  kind: contains
  text_a: A thirsty Peace lily wilts visibly and usually perks back up within a few hours of a thorough
    watering.
  text_b: the peace lily wilts visibly when it is thirsty
  human_label: true
- id: c7-zz-plant-rhizomes
  kind: contains
  text_a: The ZZ plant stores water in its thick rhizomes, which is why it tolerates being forgotten
    for weeks at a time.
  text_b: the zz plant stores water in its thick rhizomes
  human_label: true
- id: c8-jade-plant-window
  kind: contains
  text_a: A south- or west-facing window is a strong choice for the Jade plant indoors, giving it
    the bright light it wants.
  text_b: a south- or west-facing window is a strong choice for the jade plant
  human_label: true
- id: c9-philodendron-drooping
  kind: contains
  text_a: Drooping or yellowing lower leaves on a Philodendron often signal overwatering rather than
    thirst.
  text_b: drooping or yellowing lower leaves on a philodendron often signal overwatering
  human_label: true
- id: c10-dracaena-drainage
  kind: contains
  text_a: Let excess water drain fully and never leave Dracaena sitting in a saucer of water, since
    it is sensitive to overwatering.
  text_b: dracaena is sensitive to overwatering
  human_label: true
- id: c11-rubber-plant-sap
  kind: contains
  text_a: The milky latex sap of the Rubber plant can irritate the skin of people who handle damaged
    stems or leaves, so wash your hands after pruning.
  text_b: the milky latex sap of the rubber plant can irritate the skin
  human_label: true
- id: c12-fiddle-leaf-fig-drafts
  kind: contains
  text_a: Keep the Fiddle-leaf fig away from cold drafts and heating vents, which stress the foliage.
  text_b: keep the fiddle-leaf fig away from cold drafts and heating vents
  human_label: true
- id: c13-orchid-roots
  kind: contains
  text_a: Roots that turn silvery-grey signal that the Orchid is ready for its next drink, while
    plump green roots mean it has enough moisture.
  text_b: roots that turn silvery-grey signal that the orchid is ready for its next drink
  human_label: true
- id: c14-boston-fern-temperature
  kind: contains
  text_a: A spot that stays between 18 and 24 degrees Celsius suits the Boston fern well throughout
    the year.
  text_b: a spot between 18 and 24 degrees celsius suits the boston fern
  human_label: true
- id: c15-monstera-fact-absent
  kind: contains
  text_a: This answer explains the Monstera's light needs and how often to rotate the pot for even
    growth.
  text_b: repot the monstera every 1 to 2 years in spring
  human_label: false
- id: c16-peace-lily-fact-absent
  kind: contains
  text_a: This answer covers how often to water the Peace lily and where to place it for the best
    light.
  text_b: the sap of the peace lily can irritate human skin
  human_label: false
- id: c17-zz-plant-fact-absent
  kind: contains
  text_a: This answer explains the ZZ plant's tolerance for low light and forgiving watering schedule.
  text_b: the zz plant contains insoluble calcium oxalate crystals in all parts of the plant
  human_label: false
- id: c18-philodendron-fact-absent
  kind: contains
  text_a: This answer describes Philodendron's preferred light and how often to rotate the pot.
  text_b: philodendron is toxic to cats and dogs due to calcium oxalate crystals
  human_label: false
- id: c19-dracaena-fact-absent
  kind: contains
  text_a: This answer explains how often to water Dracaena and how to avoid brown leaf tips.
  text_b: dracaena contains saponins that can cause dilated pupils in cats
  human_label: false
- id: c20-rubber-plant-fact-absent
  kind: contains
  text_a: This answer covers the Rubber plant's light preference and how to rotate it for even growth.
  text_b: overwatering the rubber plant is a common cause of yellowing lower leaves and root rot
  human_label: false
- id: c21-orchid-fact-absent
  kind: contains
  text_a: This answer explains how to tell when an Orchid's roots need water again.
  text_b: the orchid will scorch under direct midday sun
  human_label: false
- id: c22-boston-fern-fact-absent
  kind: contains
  text_a: This answer describes how often to water the Boston fern and how to raise humidity around
    it.
  text_b: harsh midday sun will scorch the fronds of the boston fern and bleach their green color
  human_label: false
- id: e4-es-zz-plant-watering-paraphrase
  kind: equivalent
  text_a: Riega la planta ZZ solo cuando los 2 centimetros superiores del sustrato se hayan secado
    por completo.
  text_b: Riega la planta ZZ unicamente cuando los 2 centimetros superiores del sustrato se hayan
    secado por completo.
  human_label: true
- id: e5-es-jade-light-paraphrase
  kind: equivalent
  text_a: La planta de jade necesita luz brillante y tolera varias horas de sol directo al dia.
  text_b: La planta de jade necesita luz brillante y tolera varias horas de sol directo cada dia.
  human_label: true
- id: e6-es-dracaena-toxic-paraphrase
  kind: equivalent
  text_a: La Dracaena es toxica para gatos y perros segun la referencia citada.
  text_b: La referencia citada indica que la Dracaena es toxica para gatos y perros.
  human_label: true
- id: e7-en-monstera-watering-paraphrase
  kind: equivalent
  text_a: Water the Monstera when the top 2 to 3 centimeters of soil have dried out.
  text_b: Water the Monstera once the top 2 to 3 centimeters of soil have dried out.
  human_label: true
- id: e8-en-orchid-toxicity-paraphrase
  kind: equivalent
  text_a: The cited reference does not list Orchid as toxic to cats or dogs.
  text_b: The cited reference does not list the Orchid as toxic to cats or dogs.
  human_label: true
- id: e9-en-philodendron-light-paraphrase
  kind: equivalent
  text_a: Philodendron grows best in bright, indirect light near an east- or north-facing window.
  text_b: Philodendron grows best in bright indirect light near an east or north facing window.
  human_label: true
- id: e10-es-calathea-watering-paraphrase
  kind: equivalent
  text_a: Riega tu Calatea cuando la pulgada superior de la mezcla haya comenzado a secarse.
  text_b: Riega tu Calatea cuando la pulgada superior de la mezcla comience a secarse.
  human_label: true
- id: e11-es-rubber-plant-watering-paraphrase
  kind: equivalent
  text_a: La planta de caucho prefiere que se seque la pulgada superior del sustrato antes de volver
    a regar.
  text_b: La planta de caucho prefiere que la pulgada superior del sustrato se seque antes de regar
    de nuevo.
  human_label: true
- id: e12-en-boston-fern-light-paraphrase
  kind: equivalent
  text_a: The Boston fern grows best in bright, indirect light and tolerates moderate shade.
  text_b: The Boston fern grows best in bright indirect light and tolerates moderate shade.
  human_label: true
- id: e13-es-monstera-watering-vs-toxicity
  kind: equivalent
  text_a: Riega la Monstera cuando los 2 a 3 centimetros superiores del sustrato se hayan secado.
  text_b: La Monstera es toxica para gatos y perros; la ingestion puede causar irritacion bucal.
  human_label: false
- id: e14-en-pothos-light-vs-repotting
  kind: equivalent
  text_a: Pothos grows best in bright, indirect light and keeps its variegation strongest under those
    conditions.
  text_b: Repot a Pothos every one to two years, or when roots begin circling the pot.
  human_label: false
- id: e15-es-orchid-vs-fern-watering
  kind: equivalent
  text_a: Riega la Orquidea cada siete a diez dias, dejando que el sustrato se seque un poco entre
    riegos.
  text_b: El helecho de Boston necesita agua dos o tres veces por semana en una habitacion calida
    y luminosa.
  human_label: false
- id: e16-es-brown-tips-synonym-paraphrase
  kind: equivalent
  text_a: Las puntas marrones de las hojas suelen deberse a la baja humedad.
  text_b: El resecamiento de las puntas foliares casi siempre se origina por ambientes poco humedos.
  human_label: true
- id: e17-en-root-rot-synonym-paraphrase
  kind: equivalent
  text_a: Standing water in the saucer causes the roots to rot.
  text_b: Letting the pot sit in a puddle leads to decayed roots.
  human_label: true